Kerala’s Fight Against Black Magic: High Court Urges Government for New Legislation

Introduction

Kerala, known for its high literacy and progressive outlook, has recently found itself confronting an alarming issue: practices linked to black magic, sorcery, and ritualistic human sacrifices. In response, the Kerala High Court has stepped in, urging the state government to take decisive action on drafting and enacting legislation that criminalizes these harmful and inhuman practices. This judicial intervention highlights the state’s struggle to balance cultural beliefs and human rights while ensuring public safety.

Background: Why Kerala Needs Anti–Black Magic Laws

Although Kerala is often celebrated for its social development and educational achievements, it has not been immune to cases involving superstition and occult practices with deadly consequences. Over the past few years, multiple incidents have shocked the public and law enforcement alike:

• In 2022, two women were brutally murdered in Pathanamthitta during what appeared to be ritualistic human sacrifices.
• In early 2024, the mysterious deaths of three individuals in hotel rooms located in Kottayam and Thiruvananthapuram sparked suspicion of black magic rituals that may have involved physical violence.
• Similar reports from districts like Idukki and Kollam have surfaced, exposing a disturbing trend of violence, manipulation, and exploitation linked to so-called supernatural practices.

These incidents have raised questions about the adequacy of existing laws and have sparked demands from civil society and rationalist groups for a stronger legal framework.

The Role of the Kerala High Court

The Kerala High Court has been actively engaged in this issue following a petition from the Kerala Yukthivadhi Sangham, a prominent rationalist organization. The petition called for the enactment of a dedicated law to ban black magic, sorcery, and related practices, which they described as “inhuman evil practices.”

The court, recognizing the gravity of the situation, has directed the state government to clarify its position on this matter. Most recently, the court requested the government to file a detailed affidavit explaining whether it supports the proposed legislation and its plans regarding the issue.

The Proposed Anti–Black Magic Bill

The push for legislation is not new. The Kerala Law Reforms Commission, led by former Justice K.T. Thomas, had drafted the Kerala Prevention and Eradication of Inhuman Evil Practices, Sorcery and Black Magic Bill, 2019. This draft law addresses various harmful practices through clear provisions:

• Prohibited Acts: The bill seeks to criminalize acts such as ritual killings, invoking spirits to harm others, physical torture disguised as exorcism, and forcing people to refuse medical treatment in favor of superstition or charms.
• Punishments: It proposes penalties ranging from a minimum of one year to a maximum of seven years of imprisonment for offenders. In cases where the victim dies, life imprisonment may be imposed. Fines ranging from ₹5,000 to ₹50,000 are also prescribed.
• Enforcement Mechanisms: Police authorities would have the power to investigate, search premises, and seize objects related to black magic practices. The bill also mandates publicizing the names of offenders as a deterrent.
• Religious and Cultural Protections: To respect constitutional freedoms, harmless religious rituals that do not cause injury or harm would be exempt from the law.

Why the Delay in Legislation?

Despite being drafted in 2019, the bill has yet to become law. The reasons for this delay are multifaceted:

• Political Sensitivities: Kerala’s society is diverse and deeply religious, with many traditional practices deeply embedded in culture. Legislators have been cautious, wary of backlash from religious groups who may perceive such laws as an attack on faith.
• Legal Complexity: Defining what constitutes “black magic” or “superstition” without infringing on fundamental rights like freedom of religion is challenging. The government needs to carefully frame the law to avoid arbitrary enforcement or misuse.
• Public Awareness and Debate: Some lawmakers believe more public consultation and awareness campaigns are needed before the law is enacted, to ensure that the law addresses real harm without undermining cultural identity.

Challenges in Balancing Law and Culture

Kerala’s effort to legislate against black magic practices raises the classic legal dilemma—how to curb harmful acts linked to superstition without curtailing religious freedom. The challenge lies in:

• Clear Definitions: The law must precisely identify practices that cause physical or mental harm without generalizing or criminalizing traditional rituals that are peaceful and culturally significant.
• Preventing Misuse: Vague laws risk being used to settle personal scores, suppress dissent, or harass minority groups.
• Education and Scientific Temper: Laws alone may not suffice unless combined with public education to promote rational thinking and reduce superstition.

The Way Forward: Government and Judiciary Roles

The Kerala High Court’s recent directive for the government to provide its position signals judicial impatience with the legislative delay. This judicial nudging could prompt the state to act swiftly, either by adopting the draft bill with necessary amendments or by proposing a fresh framework.

If the government remains indecisive, the court could impose directives to ensure action, demonstrating the judiciary’s willingness to safeguard citizens’ lives and rights.

Broader Impact and Significance

• Protecting Vulnerable Populations: Many black magic-related abuses target women, children, and marginalized individuals, often under coercion or deception. A law would provide legal recourse and protection.
• Setting a Precedent: Kerala could become a model for other Indian states grappling with similar issues, encouraging nationwide efforts to combat superstition-based violence.
• Promoting Rationalism: By legislating against exploitative occult practices, Kerala reinforces its commitment to scientific temper and progressive values.

Conclusion

Kerala stands at a crucial crossroads between respecting its rich cultural traditions and confronting the dangers posed by harmful superstitions and black magic rituals. The active intervention of the Kerala High Court is driving a much-needed dialogue on safeguarding human rights and public safety.

For meaningful change, the state government must craft a law that is firm yet fair—one that criminalizes truly inhuman practices while safeguarding religious freedoms. Alongside legislation, public education and awareness will be key to eradicating superstition and promoting a culture of reason and compassion.

This legal battle reflects Kerala’s larger journey towards social justice and human dignity—one that may inspire other regions in India and beyond.

Frequently Asked Questions:

Read more:

Karnataka’s Proposed Fake News Law: A Bold Step or a Threat to Free Speech?